Because components of the Wahls diet may affectinflammation, oxidative stress and mitochondrialdysfunction, it has plausible mechanisms for slow-ing ALS. Although a cross-sectional study suggeststhe intake of certain macro- and micronutrientsenriched in the Wahls diet was associated with bet-ter baseline motor function and lower risk for get-ting ALS, no case reports or clinical trials areshowing the Wahls diet affects disease progressionor survival in PALS. On the contrary, the clinicaltrial in MS patients showing significant weight lossand essential vitamin and mineral deficienciesraises serious concerns; two thirds of PALS alreadyexperience weight loss at the time of diagnosis,and weight loss is a strong predictive factor for fastdisease progression and shorter survival.Therefore, we cannot endorse the Wahls protocolfor slowing ALS progression.
Patient trials
PoNS Device
Considering the fact that electrical stimulation was first used as a medical treatment more than 100 years ago (30), and first used as an ALS treatment 30 years ago (31), it is disappointing that we have yet to find a clear way to use this to help PALS. PoNS™ is a newer version of this. There is a vague theoretical mechanism (neuromodulation) by which PoNS™ could potentially modulate neuroplasticity in the brainstem and cortex, but whether it provides any beneficial or deleterious effects on ALS progression is currently unknown. While there are early, promising data showing that the PoNS™ device improving gait in patients with multiple sclerosis, this may not translate to PALS. There are no pre-clinical data or clinical trials of PoNS™ therapy in PALS to determine efficacy. The PoNS™ device appears to be relatively safe but its substantial cost and prescription-only status will limit accessibility for PALS. Given the current lack of ALS-relevant data, we cannot currently support the use of PoNS™ therapy to slow, stop, or reverse ALS progression. We hope that this review of PoNS™ and the broader topic of neurostimulation spurs future research toward helping PALS.
Ashwagandha
WS appears reasonably safe, has plausible mechanisms by which it might slow ALS progression, and has promising data obtained in multiple different clinical models of ALS. While there are also some interesting self-reports from PALS and one verified ALS reversal on a compound containing WS, these must be interpreted with caution because of the variable natural history of ALS progression. We conclude that WS is a reasonable compound for ALS trials, and we look forward to the results of the one trial that is underway.
Lions Mane
While Lion’s Mane may have neuroprotective, neurotrophic, antioxidant, and anti-inflammatory properties that could, at least in theory, potentially help ALS, there are still no studies in ALS-relevant cell or animal models, nor in humans with ALS. Therefore, we do not have enough information to support the current use of Lion’s Mane for treating ALS. We hope to see the validation of its neuroprotective and anti-inflammatory benefits in ALS disease models, which may ultimately lead to clinical trials in PALS.
Insulin
Insulin treatment for ALS is an intriguing area for future research. However, the risks of insulin administration are significant and potentially lethal. Currently, there is no clinical evidence to support its use in PALS. Therefore, we cannot endorse insulin as a way to slow, stop, or reverse ALS progression at this time.
Caffeine
Caffeine is inexpensive, reasonably safe at doses of under 400 mg daily, and has plausible mechanisms by which it could slow ALS progression. However, data from pre-clinical models are contradictory and a two cohort studies showed no clear relationship between caffeine intake and ALS progression. Based on all this, we cannot endorse caffeine as anALS treatment.
Astaxanthin
There are theoretical mechanisms supporting the potential role of astaxanthin in the treatment of ALS, however, there are no ALS-specific pre-clinical data exploring this treatment. One verified“ALS reversal” occurred while taking astaxanthin in the setting of a cocktail of various other therapies—an association that does not prove causality. There have been no clinical trials of astaxanthin in PALS. Natural astaxanthin appears to be generally safe and inexpensive. We believe there is a need for further pre-clinical and/or clinical trials of natural astaxanthin in disease models and PALS, respectively, to further elucidate efficacy.
Ozone
Ozone therapy has possible mechanisms for treating ALS. A preclinical study in very small numbers of mTDP43 mice (which has yet to be peerreviewed) suggested benefits on motor function and survival (21,22); however, these benefits were not seen in mSOD1 mice (20). One verified “ALS reversal” occurred on a cocktail of alternative therapies including ozone (24); an association such as this does not prove causality. There have been no trials of ozone therapy in PALS. There may be potentially serious side effects associated with ozone therapy, depending on the dose (31). Based on all this, we support further investigation of ozone therapy in ALS cell or animal models, but we cannot yet recommend it as an ALS treatment.